Performance Review Season

I have twelve performance reviews to write this month. I expect to use, on average, 4 hours for each review. That time I will spend reviewing notes, emails, artifacts from calendar invites and code that each person has contributed to our collective.

Years ago, the first time I wrote an appraisal on someone else’s performance, it was distasteful. I didn’t have enough content, and I’m pretty sure I wrote something vacuous. I learned the hard way that it’s not the review that is meaningful. It’s important, to be sure – a piece of paper that gets tucked in the paper file cabinet in the local HR office. These days, hopefully electronically scanned.

When I was in school, the best classes I had were when the final exam of the semester was a culmination of all that I had been taught during the weeks leading up to the test. The test was whether I had paid attention and learned throughout the year. My worst experiences were when a sadistic teacher put all-new content on the final exam. The sickening surprise of not being prepared to answer exam questions was a big turnoff.

Modern performance reviews should not be surprises. If I find myself writing something in the review that I had not at least once had a prior face to face conversation with the team member, it’s not fair game for the review. At least not in a negative or punitive sense.

In fact, each year the whole “write once per year” appraisal process feels increasingly like it’s from a bygone era. In the software industry, goals, team dynamics and performance change so rapidly that writing a one or two page appraisal once or even twice a year is woefully inadequate for effectively managing performance.

The meaningful part of the whole process is those every 2 or 3 week one-on-ones with team members. So, this season, I rest comforted that I took decent notes and consistently communicated with people throughout the year.

For my teams, it’s the 200+ micro-feedback points throughout the year that are meaningful, not the 12 biggies that happen in February. Every season is Performance Review Season.

This entry was posted in Integrity, Software and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.